As Band Aid commemorates its 40th anniversary, criticisms of its portrayal of Africa are resurfacing, highlighting the balance between philanthropic efforts and cultural representation. While figures like Bob Geldof defend the original charity efforts, many, including current artists like Ed Sheeran and cultural commentators, argue that such initiatives perpetuate harmful stereotypes about Africans. The discussion emphasizes the need for a shift in how African narratives are presented in global fundraising campaigns, advocating for a future where African voices are central to their own stories.