Following the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in New York City, an unusual fandom has emerged around the suspect, Luigi Mangione. This phenomenon reflects a growing anger towards the American healthcare system, as social media users have turned Mangione into a controversial figure. His arrest led to the creation of pro-Mangione content and online defenses, while critiques of the healthcare system dominate discussions. This troubling trend raises questions about how social media blurs the lines between admiration and condemnation, as well as the normalization of violence against corporate elites.